I don't quite understand, which 'reports' are you referencing Blurry?
If you are talking about reports of admin abuse, I agree with the system, and in fact it's something I had suggested but not explained in
this post - as you can see, some admins are part of the 'discipline team'. What I hadn't explained is that I thought it would be a good idea to model the management in a similar way to how we do in VU, with different circles (admin/discipline, recruitment, development).
But what I am referencing in my proposal and in the explanation above is not just admin abuse, it's pervasive systemic bias in staff-related actions, and the security of the server becoming contingent on the cohesion of one particular group, i.e. a clan. Systemic bias would influence the treatment of admin abuse reports, however it would also influence the selection of new staff, the power relations amongst staff, and the development of the server (which new features/rules/events get approved or denied). Once again, the three areas that the staff work in, which we need to bear in mind in all discussions of management: admin/discipline, recruitment, and development.
The security contingency I mention is the fear that were the server to become reliant on one group running it, then if that group splits or has problems, the server stands a high chance of also splitting or having problems. The example of this having happened in the past is ULK, and the obvious example of this potentially happening in the future is VU. As the ex-leader and a current member of VU I don't see this as a likely eventuality, however anything is possible, and I am trying to suggest a system that would protect the server from any issues that VU might have. I am also trying to protect my clan from being accused of bias/domination when the server is running, as ULK frequently was (sometimes rightly, sometimes not).
On a side note: Aki, your input would be appreciated if it were sooner rather than later. As I said previously, it would be nice if this conversation doesn't have to last too long, and we can actually start making this thing.