I thought that this was some sort of new minigame topic where players could put their own "what would have happened?" thoughts related to VC:MP. Sad.
Example: What would have happened if ULK had never been split.
Cool idea! @Sezar, do you mind if we hijack your thread for this forum game?
My answer to Calhoun's question would be: if ULK still existed, VC:MP would be much more toxic than it is right now. Open racism, homophobia, sexism and aggression would be more common, and newbies would aspire to these values. Clan wars would also be more interesting, though.
But ULK was never going to be able to sustain its old vs new player dynamic. If it hadn't split then, because of Aki, it would have split some other time further down the line. Many of the old-school ULKs treated the new ones like shit. There was a pretty harsh hierarchy, even if the 'new' members had been in the clan for years, the old ones would always assert their authority over them. There's no way that this could have been sustained.